+ Makeup

Beauty Review: Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer

s1868280-main-lheroLike many women, I suffer from under-eye darkness.  I’ve tried all the creams, serums, lotions, and potions they sell to rid myself of this scourge, but none of it works so well that I can abandon concealer.

My regular under-eye routine layers Lancome’s Color Correcting Primer and Maybelline’s Age Rewind Concealer.  It works well, but I wanted something with more oomph.  I didn’t just wanted to cover or minimize, I wanted to hide my circles.  So I decided to It! Cosmetics Bye Bye Under-Eye Concealer a go.

The first thing I noticed about the Bye Bye concealer was how thick it is.  Most concealers are liquid or creamy, but this concealer is like building mortar.

As a result, it only takes a tiny bit of concealer to cover your under-eye area.  If you apply more than a tiny amount, you look like you’re wearing theatre makeup, so apply sparingly.  But even applying just a minuscule amount, I found the concealer settled into the acne scars under my eyes and could look very heavy if I wasn’t careful.  I ended up blending and re-blending as the day went on.

This is the double-edged sword of the Bye Bye concealer.  It definitely hides your circles.  But it can also look like you’re wearing two-pounds of makeup unless you grab a teardrop sponge and blend til your fingers are numb.  This thickness is especially evident if you wear lighter foundation or BB cream.

Bottom line, if you have really dark under-eye circles, I recommend giving this product a try.  Blend it well, thin it out with a bit of primer if necessary.  But if you think it looks heavy on your skin, it does.  Some women like the perfectly made over makeup look, but it’s not for me.  So I’m going to skip this thick concealer and go back to my regular routine.



  1. Petite Curves Ahead says:

    I’ve found that layering the Lancome CC primer (thanks to your recommendation! such a great product) with Glossier’s stretch concealer is the winning combo for me. The primer goes on nice and opaque if you want it to but dries matte and does. not. move. The Glossier concealer is so lightweight that all it does it take the color back where it needs to be. It’s perfection, I tell you

    October 18, 2016/Reply
  2. Sara says:

    Ooh always on the hunt for under eye concealer! I’ve been using Bobbi Brown corrector and it works but needs another layer of concealer on top, so I’ve been looking for one stop job. Did a makeover at a shop, and they used Too Faced’s Born this Way Concealer and I’m LOVING IT!

    October 19, 2016/Reply
  3. Mercedes says:

    I’m Iranian (and have hereditary dark circles) and a toddler at home (which only makes them worse) and I swear by Cle de Peau concealer. It has wonderful coverage and stays put all day. It’s $$ but worth every penny in my opinion.

    October 23, 2016/Reply
  4. Beth says:

    Your pharmacist reader wants to make sure it’s not allergies contributing to your dark circles. I’ve heard dermatologists say the first thing they do when a patient complains of under eye circles is have them take loratadine (or any non-drowsy antihistamine) every day for a month. Love the blog, as do my family. “Belle said” has been used more than once in conversation.

    October 27, 2016/Reply