BPGP: Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil

May 31, 2012

When I decide that I want to try a new makeup product, I become very impatient. I want to try it NOW. Not tomorrow, not next week, right.this.minute.  So when I visited every beauty counter within a 5 mile radius of my apartment looking for the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil ($24) and was told that it was sold out everywhere, that just made me want it more.

“It’s our most popular product, we can’t keep it in stock,” said a chorus of store clerks. 

I needed this liner! So I impatiently waited, for three weeks, until my order finally arrived from Sephora.

Now, I am a huge fan of most of Bobbi’s products. She makes my favorite blush, my favorite bronzer and my favorite gel eyeliner.  So I thought that this pencil would also enter the realm of beloved products, but boy, was I wrong. 

I purchased the black plum pencil because my favorite Bobbi Liner is the violet ink gel.  The color was not a deep eggplant, as advertised, but more of a dark smoky mauve.  Disappointing.

The pencil came with a sharpener, but no matter how much I sharpened, and boy, did I sharpen, I could not get the fine line that I’m used to.  The second the pencil touched the warm skin on my eye it melted into a thick mauve line. Yippee.

The other issue was that you could not darken the line to save your life.  I would apply one coat, which went on moderately opaque.  Wanting a darker, heavier color, I applied again.  No change.  So I applied one.more.time and was shocked when the pencil marred the existing line, leaving me with an application that could best be described as Early Morning Heroin Addict Chic.

I cannot endorse this product’s color or formulation.  In brief, I loathed it.  However, I still love the Bobbi gel liner in the pot, and will happily endorse that as a replacement for women who want boldly pigmented long-wearing liner.

BPGP

share this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Helena says:

    The NARS long-wear pencil liner is much better than Bobbi Brown's version. Better staying power and color saturation. But, it also goes on thick and is hard to sharpen. I wonder if it's the formula that makes it so soft. If you want a pencil with staying power AND a sharp line AND great pigmentation, try Armani Beauty. They cost a bit more, but are worth it.

  2. Liz says:

    I ordered the Mahogany pencil after very mixed reviews online. I've had it a month or so now and absolutely love it! I haven't had any of the problems brought up by other reviews and have been happy with the results. I do tend to like a more smudged/blended look though, so don't want a very fine line.

  3. J says:

    It might be the particular color as well. I have a NARS pencil in a blue shade that I liked so much I bought the same one in a purple shade and it was a completely different pencil (much less pigmentation for one).

Join The List

Stay up to date on the latest from Capitol Hill Style!

sUBSCRIBE

My Secret Fashion Weapons, Pt. I

Have a big day ahead? Major hearing? Big trial? The presentation of your life? Gonna be at a conference with that ex? Whatever it happens to be, these are the fashion weapons that get me to the confidence level that I need to be at.

1

READ MORE 

Recent Posts

The Find: A Striped Tee

Without question, the most worn item in my wardrobe is a black-and-white striped tee. I wear it in winter under sweaters, in spring with white jeans, in summer with black shorts. I’ve been wearing the same one for years (it’s the best). But they don’t make it anymore. So here are some options for replacement.

2

READ MORE 

Three Outfits I’ll Wear All Spring

When I started this blog, influencers still re-wore clothes. There were no haul videos filled with the latest from Shein before it winds up in a beach in Ghana poisoning the planet. There were no sponsored campaigns delivering fresh wardrobes each month. The content machine doesn’t like reruns.

3

READ MORE 

VIEW ALL POSTS

Style, Top Posts, Work | April 18, 2024

My Secret Fashion Weapons, Pt. I

Have a big day ahead? Major hearing? Big trial? The presentation of your life? Gonna be at a conference with that ex? Whatever it happens to be, these are the fashion weapons that get me to the confidence level that I need to be at.

1

READ MORE 

Features, Posts, The Range | April 18, 2024

The Find: A Striped Tee

Without question, the most worn item in my wardrobe is a black-and-white striped tee. I wear it in winter under sweaters, in spring with white jeans, in summer with black shorts. I’ve been wearing the same one for years (it’s the best). But they don’t make it anymore. So here are some options for replacement.

2

READ MORE 

How To Wear It, Posts, Style | April 17, 2024

Three Outfits I’ll Wear All Spring

When I started this blog, influencers still re-wore clothes. There were no haul videos filled with the latest from Shein before it winds up in a beach in Ghana poisoning the planet. There were no sponsored campaigns delivering fresh wardrobes each month. The content machine doesn’t like reruns.

3

READ MORE 

Fantastic Finds, Posts, Style | April 17, 2024

The Find: Like a McCall’s Pattern

When I was young, my Mother used to bring me along when she would go shopping for fabric. As a result, I spent a lot of time, killing time, flipping through pattern books. So when I spotted this dress, I was instantly transported to the pattern table at a Jo-Ann Fabrics.

4

READ MORE 

RECENT POSTS

©2023 CAPITOL HILL STYLE | SITE BY LEIGH THE STUDIO